How NASA, ESA, SpaceX and ESPI Frame Their Work
4 min read
What Each Organisation Puts First
When SpaceX reported on Starship’s fifth flight test in October 2024, it put the booster catch at the centre of the story. The event took seconds. NASA’s Moon to Mars documents work on a different timescale, explaining how successive missions near the Moon could prepare people to go to Mars. The two organisations are writing about exploration, and each gives the reader a different way to recognise progress.
For my Space Studies thesis at KU Leuven, I compared their public writing with texts from the European Space Agency (ESA) and the European Space Policy Institute (ESPI). I looked at the words that recur around exploration and read them in context. The four public examples below show what some of those differences look like on the page.
- NASA
- Mission · human · Mars
- ESA
- Science · robotic · European
- SpaceX
- Starship · Falcon · launch
- ESPI
- Policy · security · EU
NASA
Human missions from the Moon to Mars
NASA’s Moon to Mars architecture describes work on and around the Moon as a way to test capabilities crews will need farther from Earth. The documents set immediate objectives within a longer programme. A reader can see how one mission prepares for the next.
ESA
Europe’s part in exploration
In Terrae Novae, ESA describes how robots can prepare the way for human missions. It connects that work to a continued European presence in low Earth orbit and to Europeans taking part in the exploration of the Moon and Mars. For a reader in a member state, the strategy explains what that participation could make possible.
SpaceX
What flight tests demonstrate
The account of Starship’s fifth test follows the booster catch and the spacecraft’s controlled re-entry. SpaceX connects those manoeuvres to its aim of making the vehicle rapidly reusable. The report lets the reader follow what engineers demonstrated on that particular flight.
ESPI
Europe’s role in exploration
In The Future of European Space Exploration, ESPI imagines a situation in 2040 and asks where Europe could stand in programmes that involve governments, agencies and commercial operators. The scenario gives a policy reader a way to consider which choices Europe would need to make to get there.
What the Framing Changes
Read together, the examples show how the same subject can give readers different criteria for progress. A flight test gives evidence about a vehicle. A programme can also be judged by what it prepares a crew to do or what it allows Europe to take part in. When I write a brief, I start by asking what the reader will be able to judge from the opening, and what they still need to know before they can reach a view.
Sources and Methods
See which words recur in each collection and how I compared them.
